Manuscript processing



Wenti Yu Yanjiu will review the paper right after the submission.
After the executive editor deletes authors’ information, our editorial board will decide whether the manuscripts should be distributed for an outside review.

If a paper has to be handled by reviewers on the exterior of our editorial board, the editorial board should turn in a list of recommended reviewers. The executive editor will invite two reviewers from the list, unsuitable reviewers with a possibility of conflict of interest will be excluded.

Evaluations from outside reviewers will be rated in four degrees: Accept; Accept after Revision; Revise and Resubmit; Reject.
Outcome of the evaluations from outside reviewers::

1、 Bothreviewers evaluate Accept → The paper will go through a discussion on the editorial committee.

2、 One reviewer evaluates Accept and the other evaluates Accept after Revision; or both reviewers evaluate Accept after Revision → Author will be asked to revise the paper; the paper will go through a discussion on the editorial committee.

3、 One reviewer evaluates Accept (or Accept after Revision); the other evaluates Revise and Resubmit (or Reject) → Author will be asked to revise the paper; the paper will go through a second review.

4、 One reviewer evaluates Revise and Resubmit; the other evaluates Reject → Author will be asked to revise the paper; the paper will go through a second review. If accepted, the paper will go through a third review.

5、 Bothreviewers evaluate Reject → The paper will be rejected.

All editors on the editorial board could raise an objection for papers that went through outside review during the editorial committee, the papers should go through discussion by the editorial committee.
Papers could only be published after being accepted by the editorial committee.